Coding and costing of mv reference signal.
Issues in updating MV ref with COMPANDED_MVREF_THRESH
to be resolved. Ideally the MV precision should be defined based
on absolute MV magnitude not as now the MV ref magnitude.
Update to mv counts moved into bitstream.c because otherwise
if the motion reference is changed at the last minute the encoder
and decoder get out of step in terms of the counts used to update
entropy probs.
Code working on a few test clips but no results yet re benefit vs
signaling cost and no tuning of red loop to test lower cost alternatives
based on the available reference values.
Patch 3. Added check to make sure we don't pick a reference
that would give rise to an uncodeable / out of range residual.
Patch 6-7: Attempt to rebase. OK to submit but best to leave flag off for now.
Patch 9. Remove print no longer needed.
Change-Id: I1938c2ffe41afe6d3cf6ccc0cb2c5d404809a712
There is a macro DEFAULT_INTERP_FILTER defined in encoder/onyx_if.c that
is set as EIGHTTAP for now - so SWITCHABLE is not really used. Ideally,
this should be SWITCHABLE but that would make the encoder quite a bit slower.
We will change the default filter to SWITCHABLE once we find a faster way to
search for switchable filters.
Change-Id: Iee91832cdc07e6e14108d9b543130fdd12fc9874
For splitmv, where partitioning is 8x16, 16x8 or 8x8, this patch
uses the 8x8 transform (instead of the 4x4) if txfm_mode is
ALLOW_8X8 or ALLOW_16X16. For TX_MODE_SELECT, splitmv can indicate
which of the 2 transform sizes (4x4 or 8x8) it wants to use.
Gains (with hybridtx4x4/8x8/16x16 and tx_select experiments
enabled) on derf: +0.9%, HD: +0.4%, STD/HD: +0.8% (SSIM or overall
PSNR, both metrics show similar improvements).
Change-Id: Ide954b000b415548ed92a7ac78e24f36e60fcf06
Pass the bool coder to be used explicitly. This avoids cases where two
different bool coders can be addressed from the same function. Also be
more consistent with bool coder variable naming, start to standardize
on 'bc'.
Change-Id: I1c95e2fdbe24ebe8c0f84924daa1728e3b054a31
Separates the logic on transform type selection previously spread out
over a number of files into a separate function. Currently the tx_type
field in b_mode_info is not used, but still left in there to eventually
use for signaling the transform type in the bitstream.
Also, now for tx_type = DCT_DCT, the regular integer DCT is used, as
opposed to the floating point DCT used in conjuction with hybrid
transform.
Results change somewhat due to the transform change, but are within
reasonable limits. The hd/std-hd sets are slightly up, while derf/yt
are slightly down.
Change-Id: I5776840c2239ca2da31ca6cfd7fd1148dc5f9e0f
This commit moves a bit of data that ended up packed with the
modes/mv/residual partition during the change to interleaved encoding
into partition 0 where it belongs.
Change-Id: Ic711a378c58d9d6a17254384f492c213a15bad92
Packs the bitstream with each mb's residual following its mode/mv
information.
TODO: There are still a few fields that should be packed into partition
0 but are included in partition 1, due to them being serialized from
write_kfmodes/pack_inter_mode_mvs, which execute after the first
partition is finalized. These need to be separated out into a separate
function, similar to mb_mode_mv_init() in decodemv.c.
Change-Id: I43a46c363601ab36954d07ebe498760e1e2e3af4
Rather than decoding all modes/mvs separately, decode them per MB. This
forces the mode which was already used form the CONFIG_NEWBESTREFMV and
CONFIG_SUPERBLOCKS experiments, and is a precursor to changing to
interleaved encoding.
Change-Id: If19ee74ac8a987846d1cd0cf2b2e02a82f1a43ad
Results: derf (vanilla or +hybridtx) +0.2% and (+hybrid16x16
or +tx16x16) +0.7%-0.8%; HD (vanilla or +hybridtx) +0.1-0.2%
and (+hybrid16x16 or +tx16x16) +1.4%, STD/HD (vanilla or +hybridtx)
about even, and (+hybrid16x16 or +tx16x16) +0.8-1.0%.
Change-Id: I03899e2f7a64e725a863f32e55366035ba77aa62
The high-precision (1/8) pel bit is turned off if the reference
MV is larger than a threshold. The motivation for this patch is
the intuition that if motion is likely large (as indicated by
the reference), there is likley to be more motion blur, and as
a result 1/8 pel precision would be wasteful both in rd sense
as well as computationally.
The feature is incorporated as part of the newmventropy experiment.
There is a modest RD improvement with the patch. Overall the
results with the newmventropy experiment with the threshold being
16 integer pels are:
derf: +0.279%
std-hd: +0.617%
hd: +1.299%
yt: +0.822%
With threshold 8 integer pels are:
derf: +0.295%
std-hd: +0.623%
hd: +1.365%
yt: +0.847%
Patch: rebased
Patch: rebase fixes
Change-Id: I4ed14600df3c457944e6541ed407cb6e91fe428b
This commit merges those parts of the CONFIG_NEW_MVREF
that specifically relate to choosing a better set of candidate
MV references into the NEWBESTREFMV experiment.
CONFIG_NEW_MVREF will then be used for changes relating
to the explicit coding of a cost optimized MV reference in the
bitstream as part of MV coding.
Change-Id: Ied982c0ad72093eab29e38b8cd74d5c3d7458b10
Extend experiment to use both vectors from MBs
coded using compound prediction as candidates.
In final sort only consider best 4 candidates
for now but make sure 0,0 is always one of them.
Other minor changes to new MV reference code.
Pass in Mv list to vp8_find_best_ref_mvs().
Change-Id: Ib96220c33c6b80bd1d5e0fbe8b68121be7997095
Adds a new experiment with redesigned/refactored motion vector entropy
coding. The patch also takes a first step towards separating the
integer and fractional pel components of a MV. However the fractional
pel encoding still depends on the integer pel part and so they are
not fully independent. Further experiments are in progress to see
how much they can be decoupled without affecting performance.
All components including entropy coding/decoding, costing for MV
search, forward updates and backward updates to probability tables,
have been implemented.
Results so far:
derf: +0.19%
std-hd: +0.28%
yt: +0.80%
hd: +1.15%
Patch: Simplifies the fractional pel models:
derf: +0.284%
std-hd: +0.289%
yt: +0.849%
hd: +1.254%
Patch: Some changes in the models, rebased.
derf: +0.330%
std-hd: +0.306%
yt: +0.816%
hd: +1.225%
Change-Id: I646b3c48f3587f4cc909639b78c3798da6402678
Alternative strategy for finding a list of candidate motion
vectors to use as reference values in mv coding and as
nearest and near.
Sort by sad in vp8_find_best_ref_mvs() rather than just
pick the best. Allow 0,0 as a best ref option but not a
nearest or near unless there are no alternatives.
Encode/Decode verified on at least some clips.
Some commented out experimental and stats code still in place.
Gain over existing code averages about 1% on derf (alll metrics)
with improvement on all clips. Other test results pending.
The entropy coding of the mode (nearest/near etc) still
depends upon and requires the old "findnear" code so
this needs looking at and may provide room for further gains.
Change-Id: I871d7cba1d1c379c4bad9bcccce1fb19c46b8247
This commit adds a pick_sb_mode() function which selects the best 32x32
superblock coding mode. Then it selects the best per-MB modes, compares
the two and encodes that in the bitstream.
The bitstream coding is rather simplistic right now. At the SB level,
we code a bit to indicate whether this block uses SB-coding (32x32
prediction) or MB-coding (anything else), and then we follow with the
actual modes. This could and should be modified in the future, but is
omitted from this commit because it will likely involve reorganizing
much more code rather than just adding SB coding, so it's better to let
that be judged on its own merits.
Gains on derf: about even, YT/HD: +0.75%, STD/HD: +1.5%.
Change-Id: Iae313a7cbd8f75b3c66d04a68b991cb096eaaba6
The reference motion vector selected by surrounding pixels that has
the best matching score is used as nearest motion vector.
The change has shown consistent gain on all test sets, compression
gains range from .2% to .6%. The variation is largely dependent on
various other experiments on or off.
Change-Id: I5552e1c2f6fc57c3e8818a5ee41ffda89af05e75
Using surrounding reconstructed pixels from left and above to select
best matching mv to use as reference motion vector for mv encoding.
Test results:
AVGPSNR GLBPSNR VPXSSIM
Derf: 1.107% 1.062% 0.992%
Std-hd:1.209% 1.176% 1.029%
Change-Id: I8f10e09ee6538c05df2fb9f069abcaf1edb3fca6
Merged in the high_precision_mv experiment to make it easier
to work on new mv encoding strategies. Also removed
coef_update_probs3().
Change-Id: I82d3b0bb642419fe05dba82528bc9ba010e90924
Previouly, the decoding of mode and motion vector are done a per frame
basis followed by residue decoding and reconstuction. The commit added
the option to allow decoder to interleave the decoding of mode and mvs
with the residue decoding on a per MB basis.
Change-Id: Ia5316f4a7af9ba7f155c92b5a6fc97201b653571
Allows for swtiching/setting interpolation filters at the MB
level. A frame level flag indicates whether to use a specifc
filter for the entire frame or to signal the interpolation
filter for each MB. When switchable filters are used, the
encoder chooses between 8-tap and 8-tap sharp filters. The
code currently has options to explore other variations as well,
which will be cleaned up subsequently.
One issue with the framework is that encoding is slow. I
tried to do some tricks to speed things up but it is still slow.
Decoding speed should not be affected since the number of
filter taps remain unchanged.
With the current version, we are up 0.5% on derf on average but
some videos city/mobile improve by close to 4 and 2% respectively.
If we did a full-search by turning the SEARCH_BEST_FILTER flag
on, the results are somewhat better.
The framework can be combined with filtered prediction, and I
seek feedback regarding that.
Rebased.
Change-Id: I8f632cb2c111e76284140a2bd480945d6d42b77a
The following five experiments are merged:
newentropy
newupdate
adaptive_entropy (also includes a couple of parameter changes
that improves results a little
in common/entropymode.c and encoder/modecosts.c
that were not merged from the internal branch)
newintramodes
expanded_coef_context
Change-Id: I8a142a831786ee9dc936f22be1d42a8bced7d270
Added the ability to optionally filter the prediction data
when inter modes are selected (excludes SPLITMV, for now).
The mode selection loop considers both the filtered and
non-filtered prediction data when choosing mode. The filter
can be turned on/off at the frame-level, or signaled for
each MB.
Change-Id: I1b783c71d95a361ab36c761b07e8a6b06bc36822
Incorporates mv_ref, mbsplit and second_mv into the adaptive
entropy framework. The mv_ref framework has been modified from
before.
Adds some clean-ups and fixes.
Results with the adaptive entropy experiment are currently up by
+1.93% on derf; +2.33% std-hd and +1.87% yt-hd.
Fixed a nasty intermittent bug.
Change-Id: I4b1ac9f9483b48432597595195bfec05f31d1e39
This patch incorporates adaptive entropy coding of coefficient tokens,
and mode/mv information based on distributions encountered in a frame.
Specifically, there is an initial forward update to the probabilities
in the bitstream as before for coding the symbols in the frame, however
at the end of decoding each frame, the forward update to the
probabilities is reverted and instead the probabilities are updated
towards the actual distributions encountered within the frame.
The amount of update is weighted by the number of hits within each
context.
Results on derf/hd/std-hd are all up by 1.6%.
On derf, the most of the gains come from coefficients, however for the
hd and std-hd sets, the most of the gains come from the mode/mv
information updates.
Change-Id: I708c0e11fdacafee04940fe7ae159ba6844005fd
This commit merge the QI mode experiment. As the experiment affects
the encoding of intra coding modes on key frame only, the overall
effect of the experiment on encoding tests is insignificant.
Change-Id: I9e4e3933adface88867ad429cee3986e529c511d
The commit merges the UVINTRA experiment and removed the related
macros. The overall effect of the experiment is a small gain (.1%
on derf)
Change-Id: Ia34b3312fb9b5b34c9ba111bf0fa78c6f78ac80b
With the NEWENTROPY experiment enabled encoding certain clips
produced invlid bitstreams, or files that had a high degree
of artefacts.
This was the results of pointers in MACROBLOCKD not being
setup correctly (mode_info_context and prev_mode_info_context).
Change-Id: Ice13e1efa8bd122997d2f8f3f1e761c6c16e0403
This is the first patch to add superblock (32x32) coding
order capabilities. It does not yet do any mode selection
at the SB level, that will follow in a further patch.
This patch encodes rows of SBs rather than
MBs, each SB contains 2x2 MBs.
Two intra prediction modes have been disabled since they
require reconstructed data for the above-right MB which
may not have been encoded yet (e.g. for the bottom right
MB in each SB).
Results on the one test clip I have tried (720p GIPS clip)
suggest that it is somewhere around 0.2dB worse than the
baseline version, so there may be bugs.
It has been tested with no experiments enabled and with
the following 3 experiments enabled:
--enable-enhanced_interp
--enable-high_precision_mv
--enable-sixteenth_subpel_uv
in each case the decode buffer matches the recon buffer
(using "cmp" to compare the dumped/decoded frames).
Note: Testing these experiments individually created
errors.
Some problems were found with other experiments but it
is unclear what state these experiments are in:
--enable-comp_intra_pred
--enable-newentropy
--enable-uvintra
This code has not been extensively tested yet, so there
is every likelihood that further bugs remain. I also
intend to do some code cleanup & refactoring in tandem
with the next patch that adds the 32x32 modes.
Change-Id: I1eba7f740a70b3510df58db53464535ef881b4d9
The commit added a clamp to the 2nd motion vector used in compound
prediction to insure mv within UMV borders. The clamp is similar to
that of the first motion vector except that No SPLITMV is ever used
for the 2nd motion vector.
Change-Id: I26dd63c304bd66b2e03a083749cc98c641667116
Pulled out super block code for the snapshot as this
is not quite ready and will need an extensive re-merge.
Change-Id: I436369b511257447a7b0ea064016cb63f5011849
This gives a modest gain on derf overall, although at low bitrates the
cost is still too high, so this can be improved further.
Patch 2. Re-base and fix 80 column issues
Change-Id: Ida2f9fa3fe75370669f6a27b37108dc602231c63
The commit changed to compute UV intra RD estimates for 4x4 and 8x8
separately to be used in mode decision for MB modes associated with
the appropriate transform size respectively. Now finally after many
other changes related 8x8 quantizer zbin boost and zbin_mode_boost,
this change overall helps the HD(with 8x8) by around ~.13%.
(avg .13% glb .13% ssim .17%)
The commit also has a few changes for eliminating compiler warnings.
Change-Id: Ibab35dad44820c87e6b44799c66f8d519cc37344
This is the first patch for refactoring of the code related to
high-precision mv, so that 1/4 and 1/8 pel motion vectors can
co-exist in the same bit-stream by use of a frame level flag.
The current patch works fine for only use of 1/4th and
only use of 1/8th pel mv, but there are some issues with the
mode switching in between. Subsequent patches on this change Id
will fix the remaining issues.
Patch 2: Adds fixes to make sure that multiple mv precisions can
co-exist in the bit-stream. Frame level switching has been tested
to work correctly.
Patch 3: Fixes lines exceeding 80 char
Patch 4:
http://www.corp.google.com/~debargha/vp8_results/enhinterp.html
Results on derf after ssse3 bugfix, compared to everything
enabled but the 8-tap, 1/8-subpel and 1/16-subpel uv. Overall the
gains are about 3% now. Hopefully there are no more bugs lingering.
Apparently the sse3 bug affected the quartel subpel results more than
the eighth pel ones (which is understandabale because one bad predictor
due to the bug, matters less if there are a lot more subpel options
available as in the 1/8 subpel case).
The results in the 4th column correspond to the current settings.
The first two columns correspond to two settings of adaptive switching
of the 1/4 or 1/8 subpel mode based on initial Q estimate. These
do not work as good as just using 1/8 all the time yet.
Change-Id: I3ef392ad338329f4d68a85257a49f2b14f3af472
This is the initial patch for supporting 1/8th pel
motion. Currently if we configure with enable-high-precision-mv,
all motion vectors would default to 1/8 pel. Encode and
decode syncs fine with the current code. In the next phase
the code will be refactored so that we can choose the 1/8
pel mode adaptively at a frame/segment/mb level.
Derf results:
http://www.corp.google.com/~debargha/vp8_results/enhinterp_hpmv.html
(about 0.83% better than 8-tap interpoaltion)
Patch 3: Rebased. Also adding 1/16th pel interpolation for U and V
Patch 4: HD results.
http://www.corp.google.com/~debargha/vp8_results/enhinterp_hd_hpmv.html
Seems impressive (unless I am doing something wrong).
Patch 5: Added mmx/sse for bilateral filtering, as well as enforced
use of c-versions of subpel filters with 8-taps and 1/16th pel;
Also redesigned the 8-tap filters to reduce the cut-off in order to
introduce a denoising effect. There is a new configure option
sixteenth-subpel-uv which will use 1/16 th pel interpolation for
uv, if the motion vectors have 1/8 pel accuracy.
With the fixes the results are promising on the derf set. The enhanced
interpolation option with 8-taps alone gives 3% improvement over thei
derf set:
http://www.corp.google.com/~debargha/vp8_results/enhinterpn.html
Results on high precision mv and on the hd set are to follow.
Patch 6: Adding a missing condition for CONFIG_SIXTEENTH_SUBPEL_UV in
vp8/common/x86/x86_systemdependent.c
Patch 7: Cleaning up various debug messages.
Patch 8: Merge conflict
Change-Id: I5b1d844457aefd7414a9e4e0e06c6ed38fd8cc04
