ec_cvt.c: ARM comparison results were wrong, clarify the background.

This commit is contained in:
Andy Polyakov 2011-05-21 08:40:18 +00:00
parent fdf6dac859
commit d8ea368c41

@ -85,15 +85,21 @@ EC_GROUP *EC_GROUP_new_curve_GFp(const BIGNUM *p, const BIGNUM *a, const BIGNUM
* This might appear controversial, but the fact is that generic * This might appear controversial, but the fact is that generic
* prime method was observed to deliver better performance even * prime method was observed to deliver better performance even
* for NIST primes on a range of platforms, e.g.: 60%-15% * for NIST primes on a range of platforms, e.g.: 60%-15%
* improvement on IA-64, 50%-20% on ARM, 30%-90% on P4, 20%-25% * improvement on IA-64, ~25% on ARM, 30%-90% on P4, 20%-25%
* in 32-bit build and 35%--12% in 64-bit build on Core2... * in 32-bit build and 35%--12% in 64-bit build on Core2...
* Coefficients are relative to optimized bn_nist.c for most * Coefficients are relative to optimized bn_nist.c for most
* intensive ECDSA verify and ECDH operations for 192- and 521- * intensive ECDSA verify and ECDH operations for 192- and 521-
* bit keys respectively. What effectively happens is that loop * bit keys respectively. Choice of these boundary values is
* with bn_mul_add_words is put against bn_mul_mont, and latter * arguable, because the dependency of improvement coefficient
* wins on short vectors. Correct solution should be implementing * from key length is not a "monotone" curve. For example while
* dedicated NxN multiplication subroutines for small N. But till * 571-bit result is 23% on ARM, 384-bit one is -1%. But it's
* it materializes, let's stick to generic prime method... * generally faster, sometimes "respectfully" faster, or
* "tolerably" slower... What effectively happens is that loop
* with bn_mul_add_words is put against bn_mul_mont, and the
* latter "wins" on short vectors. Correct solution should be
* implementing dedicated NxN multiplication subroutines for
* small N. But till it materializes, let's stick to generic
* prime method...
* <appro> * <appro>
*/ */
meth = EC_GFp_mont_method(); meth = EC_GFp_mont_method();